Is it all about 40 hectares?
Madhuri Katti (Who am I?) , Kolkata: Aug 19 2008
Made Popular Aug 19 2008
India :

Is it all about 40 hectares?

The Amarnath land row started after Government of India decided revoke the transfer deeds for about 40 hectares of land to Amarnath Shrine Board. Why did it have to revoke and rekindle a highly religious sensitive chord?

Amarnath Shrine Board wants the land to build infrastructure for the hindu pilgrims who visit the temple in large numbers every year. The land they are demanding is in muslim dominated part of Kashmir in the Jammu and Kashmir, the most troubled state of India for more than a decade. The separatists, militants, Indian troops, Indian government, Pakistan government, local political leaders, separatists leaders, the faction leaders are in a deadlock over future of J&K for many years.

Government of India suddenly offered this live bomb- the 40 hectares land transfer issue on a platter for all the groups. Obviously Hurriyat (the muslim separatists group and its faction) stalled the move and has given a larger call for Independence and BJP wanting to surge ahead in national politics have also scooped up the issue. In short they all have made it a larger than 40 hectares issue.

What happens to common man? They are getting swayed and polarized by sentiments on both sides. Normal life stands suspended. The region is highly volatile. Both lurking militants and watchful army are in a trigger ready mode.

At the end of the day, it’ll be pious pilgrims who’ll have give up the hope of visiting the Amarnath Shrine in near future. The Amarnath Yatra which is an annual pilgrimage has its own economic importance for the locals in the region. Already for more than a decade J&K has been out of bounds for tourists. There has been no development in the state.

They say Hurriyat has second generation leaders who have picked up the baton now. So much Time has flowed over the issue. Why do our governments love to sit on problems and deny future generations a normal childhood and normal life?

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Manual Upload
Sorry, no media found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
3 Stars
Government of India had no role to play. it was ghulam Nabi Azad government of J&K who transferred and then cancelled the allotment. The land does not belong to Muslims. It is a forest land, a government land. The transfer was for making temporary structures to facilitate Hindu piligrims who throng the holy cave only for a month in a year. Next time when you see the governments giving land for building Haj Houses and facilitating Haj by chartering aircrafts, providing subsidy and other facilities at Hindu’s expece and inconvenience, remember that !
2 Stars
Zakir (Who am I?)
Calcutta, India
Article 367 is in Kashmir which forbids anyone who are not Kashmiri will not able to buy any property whether it is forest or nor mal land. It all comes into Kashmir Juridiction.
2 Stars
You have missed the point. The land was not being sold. It was being transferred to Amarnath Shrine Board which is in Kashmir and whose, members are kashmiri themselves. No one outside the state was involved, hence, article 370 did not come into play.
2 Stars
Ramesh,
I agree GoI has just revoked the cancelled allotment. I also agree that as a secular country GoI takes care of pilgrims of all religions.
But the move has misfired badly. Government should have understood the ground sentiments.
3 Stars
Zakir (Who am I?)
Calcutta, India
Every Religious Conflict Starts in the Time when Congress Government is in Power. Babri Mosque Riot was during Congress Government and now Amarnath Shrine Land Situation. How did Hayward (an amercian national who IP address was hacked) sneaked off from Mumbai after the issuance of Lookout Notice. India is going thru Inflation, Indo-US nuke deal (which is pro US deal) Left party was opposing the deal but has been severed off. To get off from this sort of thing, they plotted bomb blast and Shri Amarnath Shrine Land Dispute. Left (Communist) rule is the best rule in the World. We have to see beyond the fine print. Nowadays, Muslims are exposed to be a bad element in Society, so they are scapegoat. These are all going to divert the real problem and Left Party was opposing it. Let Left be given a chance to form a government and then see how safe is India. There are muslims in China, why there is no problem from Muslims there.
3 Stars
M.K. Padhe, a Politbuero member said that the communists were opposing Indo-US nuclear deal because it would hurt the sentiments of muslims. Thats rank communalism when national interests are subjugated to communal interests.
1 Stars
Hi,

I am Richa from SiliconIndia. I am also an avid blogger for a while now and participating actively in Indian blogosphere. I read your blog posting and found them very interesting and informative. We would love to see a copy of your blogs posted here, whenever you are posting it on blogger.com. Here are some of the benefits of posting your blogs here:

We have a strong community of 500,000 Indian professionals
Best blogs of 2008 to be published in a book ”SiliconIndia bLoG PrinT”
Best blog to be printed in SliconIndia & SmartTechie magazines each month
Chance to be featured on homepage everyday

We appreciate your community initiative here and in helping build a more powerful India! Also, if you have any ideas or want to volunteer to help for SiliconIndia, we would be more than excited to get your help. Pls mail me back at richa@siliconindia.com with your suggestions and feedback.

Richa
Blog Editor – SiliconIndia
3 Stars
Shiv (Who am I?)
india, India
sir, i wonder why despite 61 years kashmiri’s do not consider themselves indians
i can understand independence but why pakistan
it is a case of arm twisting for loaves
a game started by late sk abdulla
i wonder why the public gets swayed so easily
agreed excesses amy have been committed by army & center may have betrayed kashmir but what will be achieved by separating or going to pakistan india at least is a democracy
can public oi pok go for such agitation
why nor resort ot peceful means
i have lost all hopes of bjp behaving responsibly as well
i am sure bapu would have gone for indefinite fast till peace was restored on more than one occasion he called off agitation & admitted his mistake taking responsibility for the actions of his followers
peace & communal harmony is supreme
3 Stars
Nitesh (Who am I?)
Chennai, India
It's not just about the forty hectares of forest land. This is one of the few opportunities that the separatist thugs of the valley has got to wedge a communal divide and move the entire Kashmiri Muslim population to demand a free country.
2 Stars
Hassan Rizvi (Who am I?)
Lahore, Pakistan
Where people have a will - for evil or for good - they will find a way!
2 Stars
Madhuri,
Nice story. And, now, it is a hit story!
In fact, I went to Amarnath and returned just two days before the trouble started brewing.
I found a lot of change. There was all round development. Tourism had picked up. Shops were open until midnight. There were scores of local people in the streets late at night. These were very positive signs.
Two days after that the trouble begins. The government simply goofed up! It is continuing to goof up. This issue is reaching the boiling point and still there are no visible signs of the government tackling this issue. I feel sorry about the whole thing.
In fact, a week after this started I was asked to do a column. That is one of the reasons why I didn’t pick it up here.
Keep posting such nice stories Madhuri.
2 Stars
Thank you, Vincent.
Infact I like reading your posts. Sometimes commenting becomes repetitive, so I just ’star’ them...
Good you mentioned about your visit to Amarnath. It clearly indicates that government has goofed up. Thats what I tried saying here...
I feel quite agitated when politicians send a normal life for a toss and find no solutions.
:)
2 Stars
Madhuri,

Unfortunately, a lot of our politicians are raised in green houses. They have no clue to the ground realities. The worst part is that they do not even bother to find out even after a problem swells to such proportions as this one. You cannot solve a problem unless you identify yourself with the problem and understand the intricacies of the situation. Under such circumstances, your response tends to be as bad as your knowledge of the problem. Sometimes, even worse as in this case. It is a sorry state of affairs.
1 Stars
Yes, Vincent, I agree that our politicians lack knowledge and they don’t connect to ground reality. Everytime you think this is worse that can happen and now there will light at the end of the tunnel, they keep digging deeper and lead us to more darkness.
This is being totally insensitive and there is unpardonable callous attitude towards human life and suffering...
2 Stars
Jaiyant Cavale (Who am I?)
Bangalore, India
More than a religious issue, it is an issue concerning the territorial integrity of India. The government cannot keep quite while the separatists continue to have their way in the troubled state. Though it may sound stupid and callous, Indian Army must take a very fierce stand and clamp out any signs of militancy. If the Army were fiercer, the militancy and the movement would have died by now. Indian government is being too liberal with the terrorists in Kashmir.. We can’t and must not negotiate with separatists.
1 Stars
Jaiyant,
They should have done it long time ago. They sat on the problem till the next generation grew up! Number of separatists have gone up. Now if Indian army takes over, casualities will be too high.
Its unfortunate but India and all politicians have mishandled Kashmir issue for too long...
2 Stars
ARVIND (Who am I?)
ALLAHABAD, India
Well , divisive forces have gained strength from flawed interpretations of secularism .You can never take strong actions against the terrorists because some pseudo-intellectuals believe that it goes against the interests of minorities.The separatists and terrorist are taking advantage of flawed interpretations of secularism .Worse , institutions like Amnesty International take a biased stand alleging breach of human rights when we take strong actions against the separatists .No need to mention the fact that likes of Arundhati Roy serve the purpose of these foreign institutions very well .
Add your Comment